Neighborhood Minutes

Thank you for your interest in the neighborhood meeting minutes. Normally, the neighborhood meets once a year at the September picnic. Please find the minutes below. There is a 'Printer-friendly' link at the bottom of each page. To print minutes from a specific meeting, use the link on that specific page. To create a print-friendly document with ALL minutes, use the 'Printer-friendly' link at the bottom of this page.

If you are interested in the Board Minutes, click here.

Content Classification: 

2008, September 21

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association

2008 Annual Meeting and Neighborhood Gathering

Minutes

Sunday, September 21, 2008
3:00 – 6:00 p.m.
I.      Call to order
Alan Munn, Association Treasurer, called to order the meeting of the Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association at 3:30 p.m. on Sunday, September 21, 2008 on Maplewood Drive. NOTE: Start time was advertised as 3:00 but traditionally meeting starts at 4:00 so we started a half-hour late or earlyJ
II.      Approval of minutes from 2007 meeting
Nella Davis-Ray was unable to read the minutes from last year’s meeting. Previous secretary did not provide minutes. The minutes were considered approved as not read. J
III.      President’s Report As this was the alternate rain date, Peter had a previously arranged commitment that prevented his attendance. Alan Munn provided the following report:
·         Email Addresses – The Board would like to communicate as much as possible via email. All were encouraged to provide addresses.
·         2008 Garage Sale – Sale was a success, netted $699 for the Association. Group was reminded that the BHNA board would like to have another sale next year to coincide with East Lansing’s Project Pride cleanup, tentatively set for May 30, 2009.
·         Renting without a license. Group was reminded that there is an ordinance that allows three different levels of rental restrictions. Brookfield is a residential rental restriction overlay district R-O-2.Owners can only apply for a Class I rental license.
·         Thursday, September 25th (selection of officers and scheduling of 2008/2009 meetings)
IV.      Treasurer’s Report
·         Alan Munn reported that we currently have $1,800 in our Association’s account.
V.      Guest of Honor  - EL Mayor Vic Loomis attended the meeting. He was a resident of Brookfield for 13 years. Mayor Loomis reminded us of the importance of neighborhood associations to our quality of life and of our neighborhood. He provided an update on the following:
·         Residence Inn on Grand River – Marriott is not renewing their lease. Looking to build new facility in West Village. City does not want to see current facility converted to student housing. Occupancy by another extended stay company is likely.
·         East Village – MSU/City project. Prime real estate but no access for City residents to Red Cedar. This will be a mixed use project. The developer, Pierce Company is moving concept to development plan.
·         Brookfield Plaza, Country Market location – Phipps is looking for another grocery store. Three prospects, looking for a quality tenant. Has a new concept that neighbors should like.
·         Mayor Loomis listened to our concerns about estate sales on Maplewood, loss of “No turns of red” signs and shorten turn times at Grand River and Hagadorn.
VI.      Report on Trees
·         In Pat Robinson’s absence Nella Davis-Ray provided the following report: For Fall 2008 or Spring 2009 Pat has identified five locations for new trees; two of the locations are due to removal (147 & 244 Oakland), one is due to a sick ash that needs removal (235 Maplewood) and two are open areas (167 Maplewood and 237 Oakland). The association has applied for a MDNR Urban and Community Forestry Grant. If approved, grant will reimburse Association a max of $125/tree. Pat purchases trees from Discount Trees in Mason at $350/tree. Discount delivers and plants the trees. Pat purchases Autumn Blaze maples which a hybrid of the Silver maple.
VII.      Nomination for New Board Members  - There are four openings on the board due to the expiration of terms for Peter Knupfer (President), Judy Benedict(member at large) and John Hays(member at large), and the resignation of Ryan Fink (member at large) who moved out of the neighborhood. Three neighbors have agreed to fill three of the four openings, Joe Squires (Oakland), Kristin Rosenbrook (Oakland) and Jan Bernsten (Maplewood). Alan Munn informed the group that Peter Knupfer has agreed to stay on board if we did not have a fourth person to fill the last opening. No one opposed having Peter stay on the Board.
VIII.      New Business  - None
IX.      Adjournment
Alan Munn adjourned the meeting at approximately 6:00 p.m.
Minutes submitted by: Nella Davis-Ray
Minutes approved by:  

 

Content Classification: 

2009, September 13

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association
2009 Annual Meeting and Neighborhood Gathering
September 13, 2009
4- 6 pm
MINUTES
 
             I.      Call to Order
Tim Dawson, Association President, called to order the meeting of the Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association at 4:00 p.m. on Sunday, September 13, 2009.
 
          II.      Approval of minutes from 2008 meeting
Nella Davis-Ray, Association Secretary, provided copies of the minutes from last year’s meeting. Motion to accept the minutes as written was seconded and approved.  
 
       III.      Treasurer’s Report
Alan Munn, Association Treasurer, indicated that there was not much too report. The Association dues that are collected are used primarily to replace trees. Alan Munn reported that we currently have $_______ in our Association’s account. Alan indicated that receipts will be available for members paying dues today.
 
       IV.      New Neighbors
We had new neighbors that had moved into _____Roseland in just the past two weeks. The owners are a prekindergarten teacher and an analyst. Two of the three new residents at 108 Oakland Drive attended the meeting, introduced themselves and were welcomed to the neighborhood.
 
          V.      Report on Trees
Pat Robinson provided some history of the silver maple trees in our neighborhood. Pat encouraged all to call the City if you feel that you have a tree at the front of your home that you feel is creating a hazardous condition. The trees that we have been purchasing in recent years are a cross between silver & red maple, Autumn Blaze. The City is not as opposed to this species of maple. The Association plans on putting two trees this year at the cost of ~$900 total.
 
       VI.      Guest of Honor
Tom Weibert, EL Police Chief, attended the meeting. We were informed that crime inn our City is up this year but traffic accidents are down. Tom indicated that our neighborhood continues to be one of the safest in the City. Not much happens in this neighborhood J. Crime issues addressed by the police that we should be aware of:
-          Door rattling- Thieves will go door to door under the cloak of darkness changing to see which door is unlocked. We tend to make it too easy by leaving doors unlocked.
-          Larger than usual homeless population.
-          Door to door salesmen – For profit salesmen need city permit . Be wary , they should have their permits on them. Ask to see them.
 
    VII.      Nomination of New Board Members
There were four openings on the Board due to the expiration of terms for three members and one resignation. The following Association members were nominated:
Carl Lira, 131 Oakland Drive
Sally Lloyd, 216 Oakland Drive
Dave Drolshagen, 155 Maplewood
Tom Wibert
 
Members accepted their nominations. Motion to approve all four nominated members as new Board members passed.
 
 VIII.      New Business – None
 
       IX.      Adjournment
Tim Dawson adjourned the meeting at approximately 5:45 p.m. 
 
 
Minutes submitted by: Nella Davis -Ray

 

Content Classification: 

2010, September 12

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association

2010 Annual Meeting and Neighborhood Gathering
September 12, 2010
4- 6 pm
MINUTES
DRAFT
 
I.  Call to Order
Tim Dawson, Association President, called to order the meeting of the Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association at 4:00 p.m. on Sunday, September 12, 2010.
 
II.  Approval of minutes from 2009 meeting
Nella Davis-Ray, Association Secretary, provided copies of the minutes from last year’s meeting. Motion to accept the minutes as written was seconded and approved. 
 
III. Treasurer’s Report
The Association dues that are collected are used primarily to replace trees and for the cost of community events, for example the yearly gathering.   Jan Bernsten reported that as of September 12, 2010, we have $1,939.59 in our checking account, $286.58 in the savings account, for a total of $2,226.17 in our Association’s account.
 
IV.  President’s Report
Recognition and thanks was given to Nancy Knupfer of Tomie Raines for providing the hot dogs for this year’s gathering. Thanks were also given to Dan Merkel, our grill master and this year’s Board members.
 
V.     Introduction of Neighbors
This year instead of introducing just our new neighbors, every neighbor present introduced themselves and said a little about themselves (where they lived, how long, etc.) New neighbors were welcomed to the neighborhood. Good turnout this year.
 
VI. Report on Trees
Pat Robinson walked the neighborhood this year with the City environmental specialist, Dave Smith. She reported that trees are doing well this year. Pat reported that there is a tree at 158 Oakland that needs to come down. Two trees are scheduled to be planted this month. The City has no funding to replace trees, current funding being used to remove dead ash trees. Again this year, Pat encouraged all to call the City if you feel that you have a tree at the front of your home that you feel is creating a hazardous condition. Brookfield is the only EL neighborhood that plants their own trees. Or next year Pat suggested that the focus should be on maintaining the current trees. Pat is asking permission of the Board to hire an arborist to cut suckers and limb up the trees in the neighborhood.
 
VII.  Brookfield Website – Carl Lira brought a laptop to the meeting and helped neighbors create accounts and showed the site to those that did not know about it. He gave an update of what’s currently on the site and encouraged everyone to post to the site. Board thanked Carl for his work on the site.
 
VIII.  MI/Grand River Transportation Study – Lori Mullins, RLA Community and Economic Development Administrator was invited to talk about the study and answer questions. Concern expressed about safely getting across Grand River, loss of private property along Grand River, reduced or no median. Talked about bus rapid transit option which would have a dedicated lane. Bogue to Stoddard area creates a problem for a dedicated lane. In this area would need to have a shared lane. The closest stations to our neighborhood would probably be located at Hagadorn & Northwind and Hagadorn & Grand River. CATA will need to submit the locally preferred option. Next step of the study is for CATA to host yet to be scheduled open houses for neighborhoods bordering Grand River. See CATA’s website for more detailed info on this project: www.migrtrans.org
 
IX. Neighborhood Safety Update -Tom Weibert, EL Police Chief, attended the meeting. We were informed that there were199 burglaries in the city this year. Two of the burglaries happened in our neighborhood. Both were daytime burglaries. Tom reminded all to call the police if we come home and believe that a burglary has occurs instead of going into the house to investigate. 
 
X.  Nomination of New Board Members
There were four openings on the Board due to the expiration of terms for three members and one resignation. The following Association members were nominated:
Dawn Parker, 253 Oakland Drive
Rhoda Wolff, 1625 Roseland Ave.
Judy Cunningham, 1511 Roseland
Susie Engelhart, 244 Maplewood
Members accepted their nominations. Motion to approve all four nominated members as new Board members passed. The Board was very pleased to have representatives from Roseland Ave.
 
XI. Neighborhood Concerns – The neighbors were informed that the Board was submitting letter to CATA voicing some of the neighborhood’s concerns about the MI/Grand River Transportation Study.
 
XII.  Adjournment
Tim Dawson adjourned the meeting at approximately 6:00 p.m. 
 
 
Minutes submitted by: Nella Davis -Ray

 

Content Classification: 

2011, September 18

BROOKFIELD HERITAGE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION

2011 ANNUAL MEETING AND NEIGHBORHOOD GATHERING

SEPTEMBER 18, 2011,  4 - 6 P.M.

OAKLAND AVENUE

     The neighborhood gathering began at 4 P.M. this year with a pot luck picnic, and board members provided a main dish, while others attending brought a dish to pass of their choice.  All table service and beverages were provided by the association.  During the first hour, people mingled, ate, and candidates running for East Lansing City Council and School Board were present to meet Brookfield neighbors.

     At 5 P.M., activities began for children, the balloon man, and teens to look after smaller kids during the meeting.  Our president, Rhoda Wolff, introduced the first speaker, Officer Jim Didion of the East Lansing Police Department Patrol Division, who spoke about Neighborhood Watch.  He was accompanied by Officer Chad Pride.  At 5:15 P.M. we had a chance to hear about the Lansing Board of Water and Light’s energy saving programs from Aileen Gow.

  1.  Call to Order

The  meeting was called to order by association president, Rhoda Wolff at 5:30 P.M. We began the meeting by all neighbors introducing themselves, and telling where they live.

  1.  President’s Report

Rhoda thanked the Red Cedar Cafe for sending a plate of cookies to our picnic, and to the Grand Traverse Pie Co. and contributing pies.  She also thanked the board members for their hard work this past year and the teenagers who helped out with babysitting little kids during the picnic.  A former, long time Brookfield resident who passed away in December, Verna Hodge, was recognized, and Kathy Prince gave a synopsis of Verna’s life.  Mums will be planted at the corner of Roseland, near Hagadorn in her memory.

III. Secretary’s Report

Minutes of the 2010 annual meeting were distributed by Judy Cunningham.  A motion to accept the minutes as written was made, seconded, and approved.

IV. Treasurer’s Report

Carl Lira presented the treasurer’s report in the absence of the current treasurer.  As of September 18, 2011, the association has $397.07 in it’s checking, $1834.21 in savings, for a total of $2231.28.

V. Nominations & Election of Board Members

Two elections were held this year due to the need to have the one year left of Tom Wibert’s term on the board filled.  Judy Putnam was nominated for that, a motion was made, seconded, and Judy was elected to the board.

The second election was to elect three people for three (3) year terms.  The following association members were nominated:

Dave Betts  185 Maplewood

Wayne Claycombe  261 Maplewood

Rhoda Wolff  1625 Roseland

A motion was made to approve these three people, seconded, and passed.

VI. Neighborhood Concerns

  1.  Concern was raised about the trees in our neighborhood.  Rhoda assured members that she will check with Pat Robinson and try to get a report on trees, and that it will be put on the website.
  2. A new Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Directory, paper copy will be coming out soon with updated information that we have.  It was mentioned that it is for our personal use, not for business purposes.
  3. The CATA study seems to not have anything new in the plans regarding light rail, but more likely enhanced bus service.

VII. ADJOURNMENT

The meeting adjourned at 5:55 P.M.

Respectfully Submitted,

Judy Cunningham, Secretary

 

Content Classification: 

2012, September 9

BROOKFIELD HERITAGE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION

2012 ANNUAL MEETING AND NEIGHBORHOOD GATHERING

DRAFT

SEPTEMBER 9, 2012

MAPLEWOOD AVE.

     The 2012 annual gathering began on Sunday afternoon at 4:00 P.M. on Maplewood Avenue with a pot luck picnic and mingling among neighbors and invited guests first, and the business meeting last.  Main dishes, table service, and water to drink were provided by the board members while other neighbors were asked to bring a dish of their choice to pass, and a chair.  Invited guests were East Lansing’s mayor, Diane Goddeeris, mayor pro-tem Nathan Triplett, our city manager George Lahanas, and candidates running for school board in the November election.

     During this time, people had a chance to pay their $20.00 annual dues and to update email addresses, names, and phone numbers for the next neighborhood directory.

     At 5:00 P.M. activities for children began with babysitting and games provided by Rhoda’s Wolff’s son, Gus, and a balloon man who created animals and various other creatures for the children out of balloons.

  1.  Call to Order

     The meeting was called to order at 5:20 P.M. by our president, Rhoda Wolff.  Mayor Diane Goddeeris was introduced and spoke briefly about  her role as mayor of East Lansing, and about the need for strong neighborhoods.  She mentioned that the topic of stricter fireworks ordinances was being considered after many complaints this summer.

     Roll Call  followed.  One by one, everyone present introduced themselves to the group and told their address.

  1.  President’s Report

     Rhoda expressed thanks to all of the board members for their hard work this past year, especially to the ones leaving the board.  She thanked the guests from the city for coming, and all invited guests.  Special mention of sympathy was made regarding the recent death of long time neighbor, Manny Hackel.

  1.  Secretary’s Report

     Judy Cunningham distributed minutes of the 2011 Annual Meeting for all to read.  There was no discussion.  After being moved and seconded, the minutes were accepted as read.

  1.  Treasurer’s Report

     The treasurer’s report was provided by Sally Lloyd and copies provided for all to see.  The ending balance at the MSU Federal Credit Union as of June 30, 2012 was savings balance of $1857.96, checking: $1243.27, PayPal: $19.12 =$3120.35.   For fiscal year 2012 dues were received from 56 of 94 neighbors. The treasurer’s report was accepted by the members present as presented.

  1.  Old Business

     Pat Robinson, our neighborhood “Tree Lady” presented a special report on the status and care of the silver maples, especially because of the heat and drought this summer.  Three trees will be replaced this fall by the neighborhood, each tree costing approximately $350.00.  Pat’s complete report Keeping our Trees Healthy”, can be found at www.brookfieldneighborhood.net.

  1.  New Business

     A proposal to revise portions of our neighborhood by-laws, which had not been changed since 1990, was presented to the members present.  Copies of the current and proposed revisions were distributed at the meeting and had been posted on our web site, as well as handed out door to door two weeks previous to the annual meeting.  After some discussion, with a quorum of households in attendance, a motion was made, seconded, and a vote taken that approved revising the by-laws.

     There was further discussion which was begun by neighbor Pat Robinson regarding Article VII, Section 2 of the Constitution which states that announcement of the annual meeting has to be mailed to people, not hand carried.  It was decided that a board member will check with the city about this, since this may no longer be so.

  1.  Nominations and Elections of Officers

     There are four board vacancies to be filled this year,  three are (3) three year terms, and (1) one is a one year term.  Nominations were opened from the members present and were Erica Beattie, Nancy Knupfer, Mary Beth Blythe, and Alan Munn.  A motion was made to close the nominations, all four accepted, and were elected by the neighbors to the board.

  1.  Adjournment

     After thanking everyone for attending, Rhoda adjourned the meeting at 6:20 P.M.

Respectfully Submitted

Judy Cunningham

Secretary

 

Content Classification: 

2013, September 8

BROOKFIELD HERITAGE NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION

2013 ANNUAL MEETING AND NEIGHBORHOOD GATHERING

SEPTEMBER 8, 2013

OAKLAND AVENUE

     The 2013 Brookfield Annual Meeting began at 4:00 P.M. on Sunday afternoon, midway on Oakland Avenue.  The street was blocked off at both ends around 3:00 so that tables for serving for could be set up.  A pot luck picnic was held and neighbors had been asked to bring a dish to pass.  Board member Dave Betts grilled hot dogs for everyone, with buns, condiments, bottled water, and table service provided by the board.

     From 4:00 until 5:00 neighbors socialized, ate dinner, and had a chance to meet several city council members and other city officials who had been invited to attend.  Rhoda Wolff’s son, Gus, helped look after little children. Dues of $20.00 per household were collected during this time and people had a chance to update their contact information, names, address, email, and phone numbers as they wished.

     At 5:00 the Balloon Man began entertainment for children until 6:00, so that the meeting could progress.

     Our first invited speaker this year was Kathy DeShambo from the Environmental Services Department for the City of East Lansing.  Kathy talked about her role with the city’s trees, doing inventory throughout the parks, and also with sanitation as it has to do with the environment.  She mentioned that MDOT will be planting thirty trees along the new Grand River roadway, and the importance of diversifying tree types.  She will be walking through our neighborhood on September 9 with Pat Robinson to inspect our trees.

     The next speaker was board member Erica Windler who gave a very interesting presentation about the history of Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood.  She displayed two posters that show every house, it’s location, and the year it was built, and one with photos from the past.. Erica read a letter from the original settler in 1851 that described her life here then, her farm, the crops, and native plants and trees.  Some copies of her original letter were passed around.

     Pat Robinson, our neighborhood “tree lady” reported that two trees were planted last fall from Gee Farms.  Fifty trees have been planted since Pat has been the “tree lady”.

     We had the opportunity to view a power point demonstration of our Brookfield Neighborhood Web Site that Dave Betts set up for everyone to try during the whole time.  We were invited to fill out a questionnaire if we felt change would improve the site. 

  1.  Call to Order

     The meeting was called to order by board president Rhoda Wolff at 5:28 P.M.

  1.  Roll Call

     Everyone present introduced themselves and told where they live,  Our guests from the city also participated in this, telling us their names and what they represent for the city.

  1.  Treasurer’s Report

     Vice President, Nancy Knupfer filled in for Treasurer Alan Munn who is on sabbatical to present the treasurer’s report.  As of August 28, 2013, the checking account has $415.69, the savings account $1860.78,  for a total of $2276.47.

  1.  Secretary’s Report

     Secretary Judy Cunningham distributed minutes of last year’s annual meeting. There were no additions or corrections, and the minutes were accepted as read.

  1.  President’s Report

     Board president Rhoda Wolff thanked all of our speakers and guests for being a part of this annual meeting.  She also thanked the board for another great year.

  1.  Election of Officers

     Our board this year needed to replace three people, and the slate contained two.  We asked for nominations from the floor.  The board members elected for three years from 2013 - 2016 are Dawn Parker, 253 Oakland,  Mary Beth Blythe, 144  Oakland, and John Boughman, 216 Maplewood.

  1.  Old Business

     Questions were raised about who pays for new trees that are planted.  It was explained that the board’s treasury pays, but that homeowners are welcomed to contribute as they can.

  1.  New Business
  1.  The Residence Inn -  Across the street on Grand River.  Dave Betts reported that the changes to allow it to become apartments had been approved by the city but he felt that we would not be impacted by it.  Their extra cars will be required to park in a student lot down Hagadorn.
  2.   Become more child-friendly - Heather Robertson, 240 Hagadorn, brought up the feeling that we could be more child friendly as our neighborhood is “changing”.  She suggested doing fun things for Halloween, more decorations, and for the picnic next year having a bounce house, more lights over the holidays as suggestions.
  3.   Judy Cunningham, 1511 Roseland mentioned how dark the streets are and wondered if an occasional streetlight might be a possibility, or at least looked into.
  4.   Carl Lira, 131 Oakland volunteered to set up a listserv if there was an interest for parents to communicate. 
  1.  Adjourn

     Meeting adjourned by president Rhoda Wolff at 6:11 P.M.

Respectfully Submitted

Judy Cunningham,  Secretary

Content Classification: 

2014, September 21

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association

Meeting Notes from September 21, 2014 - Annual Picnic and Neighborhood Meeting

Roll Call

The meeting was attended by current Board members Beth Blythe, John Boughman, Wayne Claycomb, Nancy Knupfer, Alan Munn, and Rhoda Wolff.

Proof of Due Notice of Meeting

Alan Munn (Treasurer) provided proof that adequate notice was provided prior to the meeting.

Approval of Minutes

Minutes of the previous meeting were approved. The minutes are posted on the BHNA website.

Treasurer’s Report

Alan Munn provided the Treasurer’s report. As of April 1, 2014 there is a total of $1860.62 in the BHNA checking account and $1674.69 in the savings account. Alan encouraged residents to pay their association dues because it’s important that we have an active membership in case we need to represent the neighborhood in anything.

Executive Committees Statement of Affairs and Proposed Program

Election of new Executive Committee Members

The BHNA welcomes the following new board members:

  • Jefferey Johnson, 144 Maplewood
  • Ed Swanson, 245 Maplewood
  • Judy Benedict, 147 Oakland
  • Kay Ruekberg, 227 Oakland
  • Jennifer Castner, 205 Oakland

New Business

Dave Gott and Nell Kuhnmuench (EL School Board candidates) attended the meeting and provided brief introductions and Q&A sessions.

Bob Perialis (Lansing Board of Water and Light) also attended the meeting and briefed the attendees about preparedness and what the BWL has been doing to get ready for the upcoming winter weather. He also answered many questions from those on hand.

A number of new neighbors introduced themselves, including:

  • Steve Lidia and Jennifer Castner 205 Oakland
  • Bruce and Kay Ruekberg 277 Oakland
  • Nikki Wickham and Robert O’Meara, 152 Maplewood
  • Allyn and Mary K McCartney 1653 Roseland

 Adoption of Proposed Program

A motion was made to adopt the proposed program. The motion was seconded and approved.

Announcements

Heather Robertson discussed this year’s plans for the second annual neighborhood Halloween extravaganza and provided a volunteer sign-up sheet. She encouraged parents with children to have them trick or treat in the neighborhood, and encouraged residents to help make it a fun experience for the kids.

Other business

None.

Adjournment

Content Classification: 

2015, September 13

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association

Meeting Notes from September 13, 2015 - Annual Picnic and Neighborhood Meeting

Roll Call

The meeting was attended by current Board members Judy Benedict, Beth Blythe, John Boughman, Jennifer Castner, Nancy Knupfer, Alan Munn, Dawn Parker, Kay Ruekberg, and Ed Swanson.

Proof of Due Notice of Meeting

Alan Munn (Treasurer) provided proof that adequate notice was provided prior to the meeting.

Approval of Minutes

Minutes of the previous meeting were approved. The minutes are posted on the BHNA website.

Treasurer’s Report

Alan Munn provided the Treasurer’s report. Alan encouraged residents to pay their association dues because it’s important that we have an active membership in case we need to represent the neighborhood in anything.

Executive Committees Statement of Affairs and Proposed Program

No statement of affairs and proposed program from the executive committee was presented.

Election of new Executive Committee Members

The BHNA welcomes the following new board members:

  • Mike Benedict, 147 Oakland
  • Philip Eisenlohr, 236 Oakland

In addition to the new members, Alan Munn agreed to serve for another year on the board.

New Business

A number of new neighbors introduced themselves.

BHNA President Ed Swanson discussed information he learned while attending various city meetings, including:

  • CATA plans for new transportation infrastructure along Grand River Ave.
  • Plans for handling the excessive deer population.

Adoption of Proposed Program

A motion was made to adopt the proposed program. The motion was seconded and approved.

Announcements

Heather Robertson discussed this year’s plans for the annual neighborhood Halloween extravaganza. Kay Ruekberg announced that she is offering pet sitting services within the neighborhood.

Other business

None.

Adjournment

Content Classification: 

2016, September 11

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association

Minutes

Annual Meeting and Picnic

September 11, 2016

 The Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood annual meeting and picnic was held on Maplewood Drive on a beautiful Sunday afternoon. The meeting was very well attended, with a number of neighbors attending their first annual meeting.

Visitor Introductions

Guest included a representative from Katie’s Compost, neighbor Linda Brundage (MI Coalition to Prevent Gun Violence), and School Board candidates Kath Edsall, Erin Graham, Hilary Henderson, Nichole Martin and, Robert Clark.

Roll Call

Roll call was held and many neighbors took the opportunity to introduce themselves.

Proof of Due Notice of Meeting

Proof of due notice was provided and approved by a voice vote.

Approval of the Minutes of Previous Annual Meeting

Copies of the previous annual meeting were available at the meeting and were approved by a voice vote.

Treasurer’s Report

Alan Munn reported that as of 06/30/2016 the neighborhood held $3,347.97 in its checking account and $449.34 in savings.

Tree Report

Pat Robinson provided an informative report about the neighborhood trees along with plans for replacing trees damaged in recent storms.

Changes in Electronic Communication

Carl Lira presented the neighborhood’s new communications strategy (phasing out the Listserv and relying on the website and Facebook). He also assisted neighbors with signing up to receive neighborhood messages.

Election of New Board Officers

New board members are Robert O’Meara, Kathy Prince, and Bill Martin. Outgoing members are Dawn Parker, Beth Blythe, and John Boughman.

 Other business

None.

Adjournment

Content Classification: 

2017, September 10

BHNA Annual Meeting Minutes 

September 10, 2017 

1. Roll Call established a quorum. 

2. Minutes of last meeting were approved. 

3. Neighbors introduced themselves. Newest resident member is Diane Kearns (277 Oakland). 

4. Treasurer Alan Munn (164 Oakland) summarized the financial situation of BHNA as listed in the distributed report. No substantial changes relative to former times. 

5. Alan Munn discussed the unenforceable racial restriction in the neighborhood's covenant and outlined plans of the Board to finally remove those by seeking expert legal counsel. 

6. Councilmember Erik Altmann explained future plans to amend the City Charter of East Lansing with the goal to reduce the property taxes by 10% while levying a tax of 1% (0.5%) on income generated by residents (non-residents) in East Lansing. The city projects to generate additional income of about $5M (mostly from non-residents). Erik Altmann outlined that the city does not see much further potential of reducing expenses to avoid the measure. Mike Benedict added that Southeast Marble will hold a town hall meeting on the topic—contact him for further information. 

7. Patricia Robinson (1523 Roseland) presented her annual tree report and thanked all neighbors who directly contributed to the tree fund. Last year, 3 trees were replaced. Currently, 3 to 4 trees are scheduled for replacement but, to have them grow in the same spot as the former trees, time is still required to have the old root systems rot away. Pat reminded neighbors that young trees require care, in particular regular watering, after being planted. 

8. Wes Reedy (155 Oakland) informed the neighbors about the upcoming tree replacement of the downed conifer in Musselman-Ledebuhr Park (corner of Grand River and Hagadorn) and listed possible substitutes. Pat Robinson suggested an evergreen as a replacement. 

9. The presence of coyotes within the bounds of East Lansing and the presumably associated missing number of cats was brought to the attention of the neighborhood. 

10. The issue of speeding within the neighborhood, in particular on Roseland, is discussed. The board is seeking ideas from neighbors on how to address and improve this situation. 

11. A motion to include absentee votes (collected by Treasurer Alan Munn) in this year's board member election passes.

12. Members elected to the board by paper ballot (35 valid ballots) were: 

  * Jennifer Castner, 205 Oakland, 32 votes (three-year term) 

  * John Hays, 1645 Roseland, 28 votes (three-year term) 

  * Jeffrey Johnson, 144 Maplewood, 28 votes (three-year term) 

  * Hassan Alizadeh, 120 Maplewood (two-year term), 25 votes 

There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.  

Minutes recorded by Philip Eisenlohr. 

Content Classification: 

2018, September 9

  1. Roll Call established a quorum. 
  2. Minutes of last meeting were approved. 
  3. Neighbors introduced themselves.
  4. Treasurer Alan Munn (164 Oakland) summarized the financial situation of BHNA as listed in the distributed report. No substantial changes relative to former times. 
  5. Motion to accept the updated constitution passed
  6. The Board outlined the planned future steps to ultimately remove the (legally unenforceable) racial restrictions presently stated in the Brookfield subdivision covenants.
  7. City Council member Erik Altmann gave a brief update on the state of affairs of the City of East Lansing.
  8. Erin Compton (245 Oakland) updates the neighborhood on the fate of the Book Club.
  9. Members elected to the board were Kevin Poli, 217 Oakland (three-year term), Alan Munn, 164 Oakland (three-year term), Philip Eisenlohr, 236 Oakland (three-year term), and Heather Robinson, 240 N Hagadorn, to serve out the remainder of Kathy Prince’s term (2016–2019)

 There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned.  

 Minutes recorded by Philip Eisenlohr.

Content Classification: 

2019, September 29

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association
Annual Meeting
Sept 29, 2019
Minutes

1.    Roll Call established a quorum (43 member-neighbors).
2.    Minutes of last meeting were approved.
3.    Neighbors introduced themselves.
4.    Treasurer Alan Munn summarized the financial situation of BHNA as listed in the distributed report. No substantial changes relative to former times.
5.    Pat Robinson gave a report on our neighborhood trees. In 2019, the City of East Lansing helped us with planting, resulting in significant savings on replacement tree costs.
6.    The Board outlined a process to remove the (legally unenforceable) racial restrictions and to amend the deed restrictions to allow for a 2/3ds vote of members for future changes.
7.    Communications Officer Jennifer Castner reminded attendees that our association has a Facebook group (https://www.facebook.com/groups/brookfieldneighborhood/) and a website with email forum (http://brookfieldneighborhood.net/). There will also be an updated version of the neighborhood directory produced in the near future.
8.    Members elected to the board were Nella Davis-Ray @ 164 Maplewood, Diane Kearns @ 277 Oakland, Jen Somerville @ 224 Oakland, and Ben Flietstra @ 219 Oakland.
9.    There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. 

Subsequent to the business meeting, neighbors had the opportunity to complete affidavits for the deed restrictions renewal and amendment process. The Association provided a notary public for this purpose.

The Association plans to hold further open meetings in the future were neighbors can sign and notarize their affidavits. Information regarding these opportunities will be communicated through above-mentioned channels.

Minutes recorded by Jennifer Castner, Communications Officer.

Content Classification: 

2020, September 13

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association
Annual Meeting
Sept 13, 2020
Minutes

1.    Roll Call established a quorum (35 member-neighbors).
2.    Minutes of last meeting were approved.
3.    Neighbors introduced themselves.
4.    Treasurer Alan Munn summarized the financial situation of BHNA as listed in the distributed report. No substantial changes relative to former times.
5.    Pat Robinson gave a report on our neighborhood trees. There were 2 trees planted last year (1 on Roseland and 1 on Maplewood).  If you have a place for a tree to be planted, let Pat know.  She reminded neighborhood members that the trees are purchased by us (through dues collection), but the city maintains them. 
6.    Discussion ensued about the progress on removal of the (legally unenforceable) racial restrictions and to amend the deed restrictions to allow for a 2/3ds vote of members for future changes. Johns Hays provided an update on legislative matters that may impact our covenants. He noted there has been no action on HB 4676, which provides that a property owner association has the power to remove discriminatory covenants.  The pandemic has halted the efforts to host signing parties and door-to-door to try and collect signatures.  It was mentioned that we collected 99% of the affidavits back in 1999.  We plan to put a group of neighbors together to look into this further (utilizing Peter and Nancy Knupfer as a resource – knowledge of past efforts).  
7.    Update from City was given by Nicole Mosteller.  Mostly in regards to covid (limiting indoor gatherings to 10 people and outdoor to 25).  There is currently a search for new chief of police for East Lansing (last one retired).  We requested that she give us a heads-up on future work in the neighborhood in general, but particularly when they projects are potentially destructive to property.  She will also update us on how the city plans to execute deer management. 
8.    A new member was elected to the board: Steve Whelan @ 136 Maplewood.  John Hays @ 1645 Roseland and Jeff Johnson @ 144 Maplewood will stay on.
9.    The neighborhood directory will be updated soon. We are working through how to confidentially disseminate them for the neighborhood member use only. 
10.    Carl Lira reminded attendees that in addition to the Facebook group (https://www.facebook.com/groups/brookfieldneighborhood/) there is a website with email forum (https://brookfieldneighborhood.net/).  New neighbors will need to request a website account using links on the site. 
11.    There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. 

Minutes recorded by Jennifer Somerville, Board Secretary.

Content Classification: 

2021, September 12

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association

Annual Meeting

Sept 12, 2021

Minutes

Roll call (Jeff Johnson, Philip Eisenlohr, Alan Munn, Nicole Mostellar, Gail and Carl Lira, Judy Putnam and Bob Dwidz, John Hays, Anne Eisenlohr, Nella Davis Ray, Diane Kearns, David Hopkinson, Sally Lloyd, Steve Beckman, Aaron Preuss, Jennifer, and Steve Castner, Alice Schehr, Shaina, S Crosson)

  1. Started 4:05 pm
  2. Alan – Treasurers report
    1. $1,515 in dues/donations this year
    2. No expenditures
    3. Earned $900 from garden walk – will post this FY
  3. John Hays – no progress on having racial language deleted from the covenant
    1. Discussion on if our Neighborhood Assoc falls in the category of a Property Owners Association – but it wasn’t until after the covenant was already in place
    2. Remaining property owners signatures – only need to be witnessed (not notarized)
    3. Strategy to establish committees on each street to gather remaining signatures
    4. Currently at 60% - need to contact out of state property owners
    5. Covenants renew in 2024 (goal to erase that language before we renew)
  4. Nicole Mostellar (City Council of East Lansing – gave an update)
    1. Construction in our neighborhood
    2. Mayor Jesse Gregg, Mayor Stevens resigned
    3. Police oversight commission
      1. Interviewed over 40 applicants for this commission
      2. Human Rights Commission – review police department complaints
      3. Albert al fresco area (closed to vehicles for the summer)
      4. Local art in Division street garage
      5. Maybe close Albert next summer
    4. Changes in Directors
    5. Rental overlay district
      1. Bills @ state-level – city council will talk about that this Tuesday
  5. Pat – tree update
    1. 2 trees to be planted after road construction completed
    2. New park and rec director – will be involved with seeing
    3. Deer control – 70 deer shot
    4. Let Pat know if deer are destroying trees (particularly new ones)
    5. Let her know if any additional trimming is needed
    6. Plan to do a deer cull again this fall
  6. Voting
    1. 4 seats and 3 candidates (3-3 year positions and 1 1-year position)
    2. Gail Lira, Alice Schehr, Steve Beckman, and Philip Eisenlohr
    3. Alan moved to accept meeting minutes – Jennifer C seconded and no one opposed
    4. Alan moved to accept candidates (Philip for 1-year position), and unanimously supported
  7. Candidates for City Council
    1. Daniel Bollman
    2. George Brookover
    3. Ron Bacon
    4. Adam DeLay
    5. Mikey Manuel
    6. Dana Watson

Meeting adjourned at 5:55 pm.

Content Classification: 

2022, Sept 18

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association

Annual Meeting

Sept 18, 2022

Minutes

  1. Roll call (Nella Davis-Ray & Gregory Woodard, Matt Kazmierski & Aimee Lashbrook, John & Pat Hays, John Boughman, Denise Moore, Beth Blythe, Gayle Lytle Lira & Carl Lira, Jim & Judy Cunningham, Jackie & Dwain Dumas, Anne & Philip Eisenlohr, Aaron Preuss & Jen Somerville, Beth Peck, Alan Munn, Tim Dawson, Erin & Chris Compton, Kathy Prince, Shanna & Andy Draheim, Steve Whelan, Pat Poli, Jan & Rich Bernstein, Candace Merkle, Rhoda Wolff, Tim & Amy Schmitt, Sally Lloyd, Judy Putnam, Jennifer Castner, Peggy Hall, Aretha Frebig & Sean Crosson, Chad Sigmon (and wife), Pat & Ed Robinson, Alice Schehr, Chelsea & Steve Beckman)
  2. Meeting started at 5:02 pm

  3. Past minutes:

    1. Motion made to approve 2020 BHNA minutes.  Motion seconded all approved with no objections.  

    2. Motion to approve 2021 BHNA minutes, seconded and all approved with no objections.  

  4. Alice Schehr gave the Treasurer’s Report

    1. $3,500 in account and collected $700 at the picnic, so balance of at least $4,200 in account.  This will all go to purchasing trees for the neighborhood and lanterns for winter solstice scheduled on December 21, 2022.

    2. Lanterns (Denise Moore) covered the process on distributing lanterns (bags, sand, and candles) and needs 3 captains to head up the project.  Each household will be given supplies for 10 lanterns.  Volunteers can reach out to Denise directly. 

    3. Ideas for holiday gatherings can go to Alice.

  5. John Hays – our covenant will be 100 years old in 2024.  

    1. Problem: our neighborhood board has no power to enforce the covenants or amend them.  It is the individual property owner that has the power to enforce or amend.  Amendment can only be done by 100% consent of all homeowners.  John has created consent forms that can be signed and witnessed (no need for a notary).  

    2. Covenant is up for renewal in 2024.  Once we have consensus to remove the racist language, the goal is to reprint the covenant minus the offensive language and that would be the new covenant in 2024.

    3. Ability to sign today if not completed already.  Will place forms in mailboxes of homes that have not signed with self-addressed envelope in an effort to collect those signatures.

  6. Pat Robinson gave an update on neighborhood trees

    1. 2 trees were planted last year (cost was $1,345)

    2. Hope there’s enough funding available to plant 2 more this year

    3. Top Notch Tree Group in Mason has 6-7 arborists on their team.  They will remove suckers from trees and grind stumps in our neighborhood.  

    4. Concerns about the tree on Hagadorn not surviving construction; Mr. Wahl said the City of East Lansing will replace it.

    5. When asked how many trees we need, Pat said 30

  7. New board members:

    1. 3 openings for 3-3 year positions (Nella Davis-Ray, Philip Eisenlohr, Jen Somerville)

    2. Matt Kazmierski, Mark Warner, and Pat Poli (unanimously supported, no objections)

  8. Reminders:

    1. We have a neighborhood Facebook page and neighborhood website – you must request access to these through webmaster (Carl Lira)

    2. Neighborhood directory will be updated and sent to those upon request

Meeting adjourned at 5:57 pm.



Content Classification: 

2023, September 10

Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association 

Annual Meeting Minutes

DRAFT

Date: September 10th, 2023

 

Board Members:  Steve Beckman (Secretary), John Hays, Jeff Johnson (President), Matthew Kazmierski (Vice President), Gail Lytle Lira (Communications), Pat Poli, Alice Schehr (Treasurer), Mark Warner, Steve Whelan

 

Call to order: Jeff Johnson called to order this annual meeting of the Brookfield Heritage Neighborhood Association at 5:02 pm ET on September 10th, 2023 on Oakland Dr.

 

Roll Call:

  • Property owners from the following addresses were in attendance:

    • 144, 152, 164, 175, 192, 205, and 237 Maplewood

    • 103, 120, 131, 136, 147, 155, 158, 164, 205, 216, 219, 224, 236, 237, 244, 245, 252, 261, 274, 277, and 284 Oakland

    • 1511, 1547, 1625, 1635, 1645, 1653, 1707, 1715, and 1724 Roseland

  • Quorum present: Yes - 35 of 94 property owners

 

Recognition of Garden Walk and Luminaries Volunteers

Jeff Johnson acknowledged the efforts of the volunteers that helped with the 2023 Garden Walk and the luminaries that lined each street for the 2022 Winter Solstice

 

Approval of Past Minutes

A motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes from the annual meeting held on September 18th, 2022 as presented. The motion carried without objection.

 

Treasurer Updates

  1. Alice Schehr stated the association’s current account balance is $3,535

  2. Materials for the 2023 luminaries event cost $300

  3. Due to inflation and increases to the cost of replacing trees, the association would benefit from raising annual dues from $20 to $25

    1. A motion was made and seconded to raise the annual neighborhood association dues to $25 starting in 2024. The motion carried without objection.

 

Neighborhood Covenants Renewal

  1. John Hays spoke about the neighborhood covenants and how they prevent the building of multi-family homes, multi-story apartments, and other buildings in the neighborhood

  2. The board continues to make efforts to remove the illegal racial restriction language from the covenants

    1. Every property owner must sign a consent document in order to remove the language from the covenants. 67 of the 94 properties currently have signed documents on file.

  3. Covenants are due for a 25-year renewal in July 2024

    1. If the covenants are not renewed, buildings other than single-family residences would be permitted

    2. Two-thirds of property owners (62 total) must sign notarized documents to renew the covenants or they will expire

      1. All 35 property owners in attendance signed a renewal document that was then notarized

      2. Board members will make efforts to contact the remaining property owners in order to obtain notarized documents from at least 27 others to meet the two-thirds threshold by July 2024

 

Tree Report

  1. Pat Robinson, who maintains a record of the health of the neighborhood trees that are next to each street, was not present. She provided her report to Jeff Johnson.

  2. Replacing a tree requires a waiting period of at least three years to allow the soil to recover from the removal of the previous tree

  3. Multiple trees need to be removed after being damaged during recent weather events

  4. Property owners should contact the East Lansing Department of Public Works at 517-337-9459 to request the removal of dangerous limbs or trees near their street

  5. Property owners should contact Pat Robinson at 517-351-6958 to request the replacement of a tree near their street

    1. Pat has been in contact with the city arborist but has not walked the neighborhood with them yet this year

    2. A question was asked about the increase to the cost of replacing trees. Alan Munn answered by talking about the desire to purchase higher-quality trees that will last longer than the trees provided by the city

      1. Pat researched prices, recommended tree species that would thrive in the neighborhood’s conditions, and identified providers that could deliver those trees

 

Board Member Elections

  1. The three-year terms for board members John Hays, Jeff Johnson, and Steve Whelan have expired

  2. Nella Davis-Ray (164 Maplewood), John Hays (1645 Roseland), and Denise Moore (252 Oakland) were nominated

    1. A motion was made and seconded to accept all of the nominees. The motion carried without objection.

 

Open Discussion

  1. The board was asked to stay informed and in contact with the city regarding the upcoming construction at the intersection of Hagadorn and Grand River. Consumers Energy will be breaking ground soon for a project to install new gas lines on the north side of the intersection. The project is expected to last through December of this year.

  2. Gail Lytle Lira acknowledged the efforts of Jeff Johnson and Steve Whelan during their time on the board and thanked John Hays for returning for another term.

 

Adjournment

  • A motion was made and seconded to adjourn the meeting at 5:44 pm ET. The motion carried without objection.

 

Minutes submitted by: Steve Beckman

Minutes approved by: TBD